Difference between revisions of "Trip Report: Open-Access-Tage2012"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Line 19: | Line 19: | ||
**no scientific impact analysis | **no scientific impact analysis | ||
**no networking feature | **no networking feature | ||
--> It's like the web in 1995 | : --> It's like the web in 1995 | ||
*Crisis 2: Scientific data in peril | |||
**cut of fundings | |||
**no funds for persistent software development | |||
: --> data is in danger | |||
*Crisis 3: Non-existent software-archives | |||
**reproduction as qualitiy-assurance for scientific publication is not possible | |||
*My digital utopia (technical almost feasable today) | |||
**no more corporate publishers: librarys archive everything and make it publicy accessible according to a world-wide standard. | |||
**single semantic, decentralized database of literature, data and software | |||
*Roadblocks | |||
**more scientists, more publications | |||
**only read publications of high-rank journals | |||
**job applications request publications in high-rank journals | |||
**only publish in high-rank journals | |||
: --> political issues | |||
*Metriken | |||
**impact factor: negotiable, irreproducible, mathematically unsound | |||
**article metric levels are relevant! Journal metrics don't promote. | |||
*Money | |||
**corporate publishers' profits can easily finance all reforms | |||
: --> Roadblocks are political issues | |||
Revision as of 12:03, 4 October 2012
26. September - 27. September 2012 an der Universität Wien
Eröffnunskeynote: Limited access is a symptom, not the disease[edit]
PD Dr. Björn Brembs, FU-Berlin und Universtität Leipzig
- Crises 1: dysfunctional scholarly literature
- limited access
- no global search
- no hyperlinks
- no data visualization
- no submission standards
- almost no statistics
- no text-/data-mining
- no effective way to sort, filter and and discover
- no scientific impact analysis
- no networking feature
- --> It's like the web in 1995
- Crisis 2: Scientific data in peril
- cut of fundings
- no funds for persistent software development
- --> data is in danger
- Crisis 3: Non-existent software-archives
- reproduction as qualitiy-assurance for scientific publication is not possible
- My digital utopia (technical almost feasable today)
- no more corporate publishers: librarys archive everything and make it publicy accessible according to a world-wide standard.
- single semantic, decentralized database of literature, data and software
- Roadblocks
- more scientists, more publications
- only read publications of high-rank journals
- job applications request publications in high-rank journals
- only publish in high-rank journals
- --> political issues
- Metriken
- impact factor: negotiable, irreproducible, mathematically unsound
- article metric levels are relevant! Journal metrics don't promote.
- Money
- corporate publishers' profits can easily finance all reforms
- --> Roadblocks are political issues