Difference between revisions of "Talk:PubMan Func Spec OpenURL Mapping"

From MPDLMediaWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 2: Line 2:


[http://vlib.mpg.de/sfx-coins.html COinS]:
[http://vlib.mpg.de/sfx-coins.html COinS]:
* '''+''' - can be offered for every user (because the selection of link resolver is done by user)
* '''+'''   can be offered for every user (because the selection of link resolver is done by user)
* '''+''' - can be used for other services and not link resolving only
* '''+'''   can be used for other services and not link resolving only
* '''-''' - requires that the users installs an extension in his browser
* '''-'''   requires that the users installs an extension in his browser


OpenURL:
OpenURL:
* '''-''' - points to exactly one link resolver or link resolver registry
* '''-'''   points to exactly one link resolver or link resolver registry
* '''+''' - can be used without additional installation
* '''+'''   can be used without additional installation


Please note that COinS are of advantage if a system does not know to which link resolver a specific visitor belongs to - this is very often the case for free available databases and repositories. Subscription based resources can map users to the institution granting the access. Integrating a lookup in an OpenURL resolver registry could bridge the gap. --[[User:Inga|Inga]] 15:25, 13 March 2009 (UTC)
Please note that COinS are of advantage if a system does not know to which link resolver a specific visitor belongs to - this is very often the case for free available databases and repositories. Subscription based resources can map users to the institution granting the access. Integrating a lookup in an OpenURL resolver registry could bridge the gap. --[[User:Inga|Inga]] 15:25, 13 March 2009 (UTC)

Revision as of 15:27, 13 March 2009

COinS versus OpenURL[edit]

COinS:

  • +   can be offered for every user (because the selection of link resolver is done by user)
  • +   can be used for other services and not link resolving only
  • -   requires that the users installs an extension in his browser

OpenURL:

  • -   points to exactly one link resolver or link resolver registry
  • +   can be used without additional installation

Please note that COinS are of advantage if a system does not know to which link resolver a specific visitor belongs to - this is very often the case for free available databases and repositories. Subscription based resources can map users to the institution granting the access. Integrating a lookup in an OpenURL resolver registry could bridge the gap. --Inga 15:25, 13 March 2009 (UTC)